What does blasphemy of the Holy Spirit mean to you?
What does blasphemy of the Holy Spirit mean to you?
Doesn't the Bible say its unforgivable?
Yes, but what can you do exactly that you couldn't repent and be saved from?
And if there is some act you can commit and not be forgiven for commiting, doesn't Christianity lose all of its appeal?
My understanding of Christianity has always been that you could be a total piece of garbage most of your days on this earth and one day turn it all around and be sanctified by his light when you accept him into your life.
And if there is one thing you can do where that can't happen anymore, that message becomes naught to me.
I honestly don't think 90% of 'Christians' are remotely familiar with the bible. It's pick and choose hypocrisy.
That's a great question Jon. The question touches on a lot of high level doctrinal issues, so I'll call them out without delving into them much.
I can only answer in accordance with my own theological framework. I'm a Calvinist (that's not a denomination but a belief set that arises from reading the Bible in a certain way) so this question isn't particularly difficult. I have no idea how a classic Armenian handles it, I suppose for a true Armenian, since you can lose your salvation anyway (without blaspheming the holy spirit), the answer is pretty clear. I also have no idea how a Catholic would answer it, so I can't speak for them.
Warning, this post may contain theology that may or may not be something you want to read on a jiu jitsu forum. If you don't like it, don't read it. You have been warned! ;)
1) Perseverence of the Saints (this is a core tenant of Calvinisim that is so awesome even some Armenians like it): if you're saved, you're saved. Done. Part of the idea here is that saved people are changed people. Our faith is not a list of crap you should do and not do to be saved and your sins get weighed against your good acts to determine where you go. If your sins are forgiven then your sins are forgiven, period. And then you are given the capability of living a changed life that you didn't have beforehand.
2) Total Depravity of Man: everybody is a total piece of garbage, some people just do a really good job of pretending they aren't. Jesus wasn't down with that crew and ultimately got murdered by them. So you are right that nobody is beyond redemption according to our faith. But people are too broken to choose God, our situation is such that our depravity causes us to reject him.
3) Unconditional Election / Irresistable Grace : Since you're too broken to choose him, God chooses you and saves you having nothing to do with how awesome you are, how good looking you are, what kind of good works you've done or any other thing that might cause a human being to choose or admire you. Depending on how you see this, you might say "You really don't get a choice in the matter." My view (based in scripture) is that you are enabled to make the obvious choice of not rejecting God in a way that was previously impossible for you. It may seem like splitting hairs, but from my perspective, the difference is huge. We can argue about the free will implications later.
Now we get to a sin that as far as we can tell was committed once in the entire history of humankind. Jesus, God Incarnate is walking around doing good deeds through the power of the Holy Spirit. And some Pharisees (these guys are, in a nutshell, self appointed religious enforcers / do gooders / holier than thous and have added a bunch of rules to the ones God gave people to keep people extra super duper safe) don't like it. They accuse him of working through the power of Satan. And, funny thing, God doesn't like being accused of that, that's some pretty high level blasphemy. This is where the idea of blasphemy of the holy spirit comes from and it is here that Jesus says "blasphemy of the holy spirit will not be forgiven." Now, there are some questions of whether this sin can even be committed today since Jesus isn't hanging out on earth anymore. I'll leave that alone, just keep it in mind. It appears that the sin is at some level "attributing the work of God to Satan."
Now it's time for some systematic theology. The goal here is to determine how all of this can be true at the same time without damaging your interpretation of other bits of text.
And it isn't very hard in this case.
For the Calvinist, the Perseverence of the Saints doctrine gives us a framework to understand this in. That would suggest that a Christian would be prevented from committing this sin (if indeed it can still be committed). The unconditional election doctrine tends to point towards 1) This sin is impossible to commit today or 2) God has somehow prevented anyone who is elect from committing it before they are saved. The latter may be hard to believe, but the idea that "if you walk in the Spirit you will not satisfy the evil desires of the flesh" is very scriptural.
So that's it. It's possible that this sin is no longer a factor because you can't really walk up to Jesus and call him a satanist or a sorceror. If it is possible to commit, it's still not a factor. Bottom line: according to our beliefs, you can't choose God anyway and God isn't prevented from choosing you.
Yeah Jared, there are a lot of fakes out there. Some of them *are* familiar with the Bible but they're trying to fake it till they make it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jared Gammel
yo Iam native and our people have lots of issues with religion not ur fault many were taken away at a young age and forced to cut their hair learn new language and traumatized my priests. then they were forced to deal with trauma by addicton or behviours. Now if they continue to deal with these traumas by crime who is more responsibe the priests who are supposed to represent thier god or the poor child who has to medicate thiier pain then trumatized again by society as lossers who need to make a choice on being good but no one nows what they endured. Many people put in the same place would most likely do the same. Ya so the god I belive in is not capable of this only the work that is needed to fix it if it ever gets fixed. so I think Blaspomy is like this so called priests contolled by govt money to make people into good white citizens. I sorry for spelling I not good at posting. I respect all people and really think the answer is in family.
The verses that pertain to blasphemy of the Holy Spirit (Luke 12:10, Mark 3:29, etc.) were spoken by Jesus when he was proselytizing. There is a degree of parallelism going on in his statements; referring to himself in the flesh on earth but also in the eternal sense. He was telling the crowd how to attain salvation; take his word for it (believe in him -- the Holy Spirit working in him) or leave it (indifference or he's lying -- which is tantamount to blasphemy of the Holy Spirit working in him assuming no later life repentance and death).Quote:
Originally Posted by Jon Watkins
If the question is, can a "Christian" do anything to lose their salvation? The answer is No, assuming one was sincere in their belief in the first place. However, a sincere Christian can still willingly sin, be saved and be punished (1 Cor 3:15).
It wasn't UNTIL I began really questioning Christianity that I actually read the Bible. Before that, it was more of a.. "well it's the word of god isn't it?", so why bother reading it attitude.Quote:
Originally Posted by Joshua Jarboe
My point in saying that and not responding directly to the question of the OP is that, the question really only matters to priests and scholars. At least in terms of the Christianity that I witness, nobody has any idea or remotely cares, perhaps the average Christian is far more serious in other places.
Open your minds people, Be logical about this, Religion all starts from "Misunderstood Technology" of interstellar travelers. Thats why All major religions tell the same "Remixed" story. These so called "Angels" are flesh and blood Aliens, Just like "Cargo Cults" of World War 2. The Airforce would land on a remote pacific island, build a air strip, and give K rations to the natives Who have never seen this technology. And they saw us as "Gods" and when we left they built wooden plane replicas, in hopes that that would make us " Return " All religions have " Words To Live By" but never take that stuff literally. Because it's really just a Giant "UFO" story. And I grew up in church like most people, But " Logic " has taken over.