Petition to allow leg reaping in IBJJF

Signed

GB

looks like i'll do a ibjjf event when i get my brown belt then!

I have a question. Did the IBJJF always forbid knee reaping? Or was this the result of a bunch of injuries? Like, were guys out there reaping knees and injuring everyone? Or did they just ban it from the beginning?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Scott Yockel

looks like i'll do a ibjjf event when i get my brown belt then!

---

Looking forward to watching that video!!

Where did it say only for brown and black belts? All I saw was this: "Leg reaping should AT A MINIMUM should not be an automatic disqualification against the person performing the reap from Blue Belt to Black Belt."

Done, although I'd take it a step further and allow heel hooks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by David Rosado

I have a question. Did the IBJJF always forbid knee reaping? Or was this the result of a bunch of injuries? Like, were guys out there reaping knees and injuring everyone? Or did they just ban it from the beginning?

---

That's an interesting question. They reap non-stop in judo and standing too! A reap as a take down doesn't really stress the knee like reaping for a sweep but it sure does help you slam the shit out of someone. (especially the outside reap)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aaron Gustaveson

That's an interesting question. They reap non-stop in judo and standing too! A reap as a take down doesn't really stress the knee like reaping for a sweep but it sure does help you slam the shit out of someone. (especially the outside reap)

---

Reaping in Judo is not the same as reaping the knee in Jiu Jitsu.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chris Herzog

Reaping in Judo is not the same as reaping the knee in Jiu Jitsu.

---

I wrote that in the post you quoted,

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aaron Gustaveson

reap as a take down doesn't really stress the knee like reaping for a sweep but it sure does help you slam the shit out of someone. (especially the outside reap)

---

I was just saying, a slightly similar technique with the same name in another sport that can potentially caused serious damage and its allowed. I know, like I already wrote above, they're pretty diffident techniques but realistically, compare the potential for damage between reaping the knee in BJJ and Osoto gari. I''m pretty sure people have died from being thrown on their neck.

That throw your doing in your avatar looks like it was possibly a reap. Personally I'd rather have someone reap my knee than that.

I'm not sure why you made the compairson at all, they aren't even remotely similar. They have nothing in common other than the term "reap". As to date Judo has zero recorded deaths in competiton, the potential for someone to hit their head is defiantly there, however thats why ukemi waza (break falls) are taught the first day of practice. It is ironic the reaping from bjj is actually in the Judo kata Katame-no-kata which was my first exposure to reaping the knee and when I started playing with it back in 1993.

The photo is harai-goshi (sweeping hip throw), and yes, you don't want to take that throw ;)