Another DQ @ the Nogi Worlds,this time it's brown belt Jared Carlsten. Is this legit?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chris Herzog

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loHFI...eature=related

---

Lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by djradoff

According to the IBJJF rules...yes...they even circulated a video explaining it in great detail.

---

In great detail? I disagree, not one of the positions on the IBJJF video shows the scenario that happened here.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LeeCunningham

In great detail? I disagree, not one of the positions on the IBJJF video shows the scenario that happened here.

---

Actually, there was a video that explained it in great detail but they took it down recently for some reason.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Justin W.

Actually, there was a video that explained it in great detail but they took it down recently for some reason.

---

My apologies, I thought he was referring to the video that was in this thread, and on Budo Jake's Facebook. If there was another one, I haven't seen it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chris Herzog

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loHFIyOFEH0&feature=related

---

"I need more Cowbell baby!"

Like some others who have posted, I think the worst, most unsportsmanlike part of the video is the opponent calling the 'reap' out to the ref. I could understand if he was in danger and thought he was at risk for immediate injury and needed the ref to stop the match, but this just looked cowardly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dylan Ehrnreiter

Like some others who have posted, I think the worst, most unsportsmanlike part of the video is the opponent calling the 'reap' out to the ref. I could understand if he was in danger and thought he was at risk for immediate injury and needed the ref to stop the match, but this just looked cowardly.

---

+1

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eddie Bravo

"Assume you are playing open guard and I am standing to pass. If my same-side leg (your right, my left) passes your hip on the inside, the outside foot cannot cross over the center line. It does, but mostly because the top guy pushes it and crouches down. So the ref should wait and watch, does bottom guy try to move his leg in any way? if he does, you stop the position, put the foot on the hip and LUTE. If he doesn't, DQ for not knowing rules." -Hillary IBJJF Ref

---

What's also funny, from my understanding when I did the referee course, the guy standing can also be dq'd if he forces or pushes the bottom persons leg in a position the reaps the knee.

The whole point of the knee reap rule is to protect the competitors knees from serious injury.

no use crying over spilt milk. stop making easy targets for sherdog