
Originally Posted by
Aaron Gustaveson
My take is that inter-gender is the only truly non-sexist way to go.
In principle I agree with this sentiment. Afterall, intergender grappling already happens. There have been male-female striking matches in the past as well, though mostly of a female fighter vs untrained male exhibition type thing...
In reality, I don't see it happening for a sport like MMA, which a large portion of the general public already thinks of as barbaric. Even if it was accepted some how, there's no guarantee of an audience for it.
Thing is that there would be no women in MMA if it was inter-gender. Ronda would go from phenom to out of work.
I have known some phenominal male athletes that can beat (or at least hold their own against) larger, stronger opponents. In fact, we see physical mismatches like this all the time in MMA, where one guy has to cut only a few lbs and the other guys is cutting 20-30... or where one guy is clearly in his weightclass due to massive muscles and the other is there mostly due to poor eating habbits...
Statistically, the bigger more powerful fighter will win, but this is not always the case.
With the right match making, you could probably apply this to a male vs female MMA match as well and the outcome would not be a forgone conclusion.
Personally, I'm almost always the smaller fighter in any match, so in some ways I find the idea of dismissing a female fighter beased on strength hits kinda close to home.
Now I admit she could beat my ass but we're talking pro-mma here.
Ronda is on a much higher level than many of her oppoennts and, frankly in her realm of expertise, she's also on a higher level than many males in the sport. She might not be able to stand and bang with other 135lbs fighters, but she has the technnique to bring the fight to the ground where she normally dominates.
Keep in mind, she is physically powerful for her size and she's not walking around at 135 (but neither are most of the guys in that devision). She MIGHT be able to muscle some of the smaller/less physical guys, though I dont think she would necessarily need to, given the quality of her technique. She's been training with men her whole life, many of them Olympians and World Champions, some of whom I know personlly and who I think would vouch for her abilites. And I get the impression from Eddie that she does OK for herself over at HQ too
Now, I'm not saying she WOULD win or could make a run at the Bantamweight strap, but I wouldn't dismiss her out of hand either.
Of course, I also readily admit that I adore Ronda and might not argue quite as passionatly about it had you chosen some other female fighter as your example