
Originally Posted by
Cora Sek
Lately I've been thinking about this topic over and over again. Now I'm here to get some of yall's opinion on the matter. Cora is 10 years old now and will start to fight in the 10-12 year old division (NAGA). When she was 9, we bumped her into the expert division thinking that the most any kids would have on her is about 4- 5 years experience if they started at 4 years old. Although Cora has only been doing JJ for 2 years, this wasn't much of a factor as Cora skill is well beyond kids with 2 years experience mostly due to 10thplanetJJ. However, now that she is 10, I worry that if we put her into the expert division for 10-12 years old, she will probably face kids that have well over 6-7 years experience and those 12 yr old boys will be more than she can handle. I'm thinking about dropping her back to the under 3 years experience and have her work her way back into the expert division. I do want her to compete at the highest level, but with only 9 tournaments under her, she doesn't have much experience compare to those kids at the expert division. Its like putting a blue belt vs a brown or black belt. What do you guys think?
Sorry if this is harsh but:
1. Dropping a skill level because your changing another bracket (weight, age, who cares) IS sandbagging, expect tournaments to treat it as such. Since you post about everything on the net, expect to be caught
2. Yeah I know kids can be discouraged by losses, but they are part of this sport. In a way, the kids that lose to her may be getting a better/more important experience. If your entering a division with no fear of loss at all, you’re wasting time.
3. Your concerned that the kids will have 7 years experience? At 12 years old? Maybe, buts its not a “real” 7 years if you get what I’m saying. You’ve watched kids, you know. It’s rare to have someone that young develop at a high pace. I wouldn’t be too concerned about that. To be honest, in your/our area, a “real” 7 years experience is fairly rare in adult.
In other words, go for it.