The initial problem is that a whitebelt posted an instructional. That's gonna get flamed on any site. And if this was shown by a guy claiming he was a black belt, the video would still have been critiqued anyway.
He didn't post a "what do you think?" video. We get plenty of those. Sometimes we like. Sometimes it's no good. Sometimes we say it needs work. And everytime, the poster of the video appreciates the feedback. It's not about whether or not he's allowed. Sure, technically he's allowed. But at the same time, for a guy showing that much interest in being ranked and affiliated with 10th planet, he showed total disregard for the rules.
Then the problem worsened when this was brought to his attention and he remained defiant. This could've been fixed with a simple, "My bad, I didn't know the rules." Or, "I just wanted feed back, I wasn't looking to invent anything. I just thought this was cool." Any semblance of humility and respect could've ended this. Instead, he remains defiant and disrespects a highly regarded and loved member of the same clan he supposedly wants to be a part of? What the?
And Zog's right. There's a reason the rule exists. At the present time it looks like a bad move. Steaks are delicious. Cake is delicious. But just because two different kinds of food taste good doesn't mean they taste good together. That move is just a mish mash of two techniques from highly regarded martial artists and he threw in some lockdown for the 10th planet love. The principles are solid. But they don't exactly mix and he also missed pretty big details that Marcelo and Ryan touched on.
Like I said, any sign of humility could've fixed this. Instead, he showed that he's basically an asshole who's only interested in himself.