Ok heres a perfect example of what we are referring too.
I've held back on the full story as I really liked guy and thought him and his family were super nice. A few years ago on the forum there was a bunch of youtube videos floating around about the puppet master rubber guard series. I questioned the validity of the series as I saw a ton of holes in it He had posted here a few times in the past (side note he misrepresented his rank, listed his rank as a purple belt, when he came to my school he told me he had no rank, after he left he then demoted himself to blue belt, even after he told me he had no rank).
So one day I get a call, this same guy and his family where in Rochester visiting some family, and asked if he could drop in and train. So he came in took class and then rolled with the crew. I purposely put myself in his Rubber Guard. It was horrible, I passed like it didn't exists. I even put myself back into guard just so he could work it more, he never got further than mission control and I was barely resisting. After tapping him several times he went on to roll with everyone else. He couldn't use his Rubber Guard against any of my guys, even the white belts. Everyone that rolled with him tapped him, with the exception of one of my newer white belts, who still completely dominated him. Several people on the forum ranted and raved about how revolutionary the puppet master series was and how it was going to add to the system. However he couldn't even use it on my white belts. It was never tested in competition against legit opponents, and when he finally met some, its got smashed. I still see the videos popping up to this day on other forums being passed of as 10th Planet Jiu Jitsu, its is not, and this is exactly what we are trying to avoid.
You can try to find loop holes in the rules to justify why you "think" we are over reacting. This is my life and livelihood and that of my family, so you better fucking believe I won't stand by while a few "hobbyist" think we should let it slide. Bruce you may get a chuckle out it, but this is how I feed my family, so I take it serious. Some of you throw 10P4L around like is the cool thing to do, however there are a few of us that actually live it.