
Originally Posted by
Kevin Bergdorf
Ok, forgive me ahead of time cuz I know I'm just an overly critical white belt....but I gotta go with coach Chris' entry and philosophy on this. Disclaimer: I only speak for myself.
I'm don't doubt Riley's version works, but it goes against the fundamentals I've been taught. Coach planted an idea that will stay with me forever. He knows that a lot of things out there work. But he will not teach them if they're not optimized for maximum efficiency.
Falling backward onto your back or butt is no good. It allows the other person a window of opportunity to stand up on top of you a la Royce vs Shamrock 1. The other thing that I can't get with is his leg control on the threatened leg. If you start by overhooking the leg, the other guy is immediately going to put the boot on. Yes, he grabs the opposite leg to control it, but the problem I foresee is that the one leg is stronger than one hand and so it could be kicked free and the guy can get his leg back, put the boot on his threatened leg, and stand. Bringing up the leg to go over the locked leg requires a leg dexterity that some might not have. Will it work? I'm sure it does otherwise I doubt he'd be teaching it. Is it optimized for maximum efficiency by addressing the problems that may arise from that entry? I don't think it is.
The path that Coach Chris teaches based on his philosophy of
maximum efficiency is a lot more fluid and, of course, highly efficient. Hugging the knee and threatening the pass offers better control plus a distraction allowing for more ease of entry. Getting to your side eliminates a ton of problems up front, mainly preventing the opponent from standing. It establishes position. The clamp puts you right into finishing territory. The wedge is one step further into excellent control. The knee knot offers ultimate control. And the splits offers a great back up plan to a failed knee knot. What's beautiful is that the series is so fluid that you can flow through the options without having to play stop and go. More often than not, when I go for legs, I get to the wedge in the first second and the knee knot or splits comes only a couple seconds after. I think it's smarter to establish solid control from the beginning as opposed to putting your position at risk in an attempt to rush the knee knot.
All that said, Riley is still a good ass player and has a good instructional. I just think Zog's basics are better
habits to practice first. There's a reason why Scott Yockel has been heel hooking black belts since he was a purple. My suggestion, for what it's worth......get savvy to Zog's basic series first, then go for the Bodycomb instructional. By then you'll have good fundamentals to be able to apply to the more fancy stuff.
Please don't flame me for this.