Thanks Coach Zog for your input and directly answering some of my questions. I'm just a blue belt and a university student so I genuinely don't know and am used to a completely different culture where things are done for mutual benefit out here and I think it differs greatly to say a situation like yours most of the time where as you said a day seminar means being away from your club a whole weekend. We do alot more unity stuff up here and even have what we call Jiu Jitsu Jams, basically where clubs get together for 4-6 hours in a day and each head instructor of the clubs present teaches a half hour mini seminar making it a super seminar for free (kind of like what you folks did with the first east coast training camp, but free). I know the seminars are an inconvenience to the person going out of town to teach but in the case I'm questioning, they're also being paid decently right? That was my logic. I guess I'm just more used to a smaller close knit community thing and am spoiled with all the exposure to high level guys I get through my instructor because we travel plenty for open mats and these bjj community events like Jiu Jitsu Jam.
I wasn't using Royce Gracie as a comparison (Royce would fall into that discussion of seminars with world champs or celebs you fly in...so would Marcelo...) when referencing say brown belts vs 2nd and 3rd degree black belts up here, I meant people from here who are monsters. 10th Planet may not know about them, but hey, I'm sure most people outside of 10P don't know about some of the awesome instructors part of the system either.
In regards to the idea that flying in an instructor to teach a seminar vs flying out to train with them and comparing expenses and benefit there, would you not get more time spending say a week with an instructor and having close interactions learning a variety of things if you trained with them instead of doing a seminar with them? The seminar offers a better experience for your students because now they get direct exposure but how often does the instructor spend time rolling with the host at a seminar vs if the person were to go train with that instructors gym?
I afford training through helping out by teaching our kids at my club and competing through sponsors, so my point of view is different than the average bjj consumer with a regular, steady income. To me hosting a seminar where the instructor is taking home as much as $1000 in addition to expenses being paid and the host makes nothing, even possibly takes a loss, is kinda pushing it, but I guess I'm used to a certain culture up here in Canadia, and I guess things are diff for you folks. Nothing wrong with making money, I'm just used to the mutual benefit thing. Yes the instructor is bringing knowledge but also earning a lump sum of money for their time and efforts. I kind of agree with ScottRay about stuff, but that must be because I train in a small town at a small club. Once again, no disrespect meant, I apologize if it seems that way, I just don't know enough, so I thought I would ask, and thanks for your input everyone!