
Originally Posted by
Royce Kim
No offense, but this wouldn't work.
Pumping to lock the shoulder from Mission Control is unrealistic. There's a reason why we pump from Crackhead Control.
The problem with what I saw from Brackish Waters is that you have to momentarily unlock the shoulder just to secure anything. Mid transition, there's a lot of room for the guy to shrug his shoulder free or simply back out of the guard. It looks a lot like Muddy Waters without the hand on the mat, which doesn't work; dead orchard aside.
Also implying that someone could just shrug out of a sinched dead orchard is laughable.
1.
Like I said before, there are many, many entries to this position (obviously, the “locking the shoulder” part is a key position in the rubber guard basically). Pumping from mission is incredibly difficult…. Unless it’s off of a minor mistake of the opponents elbows just as you brake him down or get to the full guard. It was my plan to show just a really basic entry to the shoulder trap to spend the time on talking about muddy waters. I get a “free shoulder trap” on people sometimes. I’ve gotten it on guys at HQ. Got it on a purple belt at HG… It happens like free New York does. Its not the highest percentage way to get the shoulder trapped, but it’s the easiest, much like the posture brake I used in the video. I saw no point in spending time on something Eddie already shows. That said perhaps I should have showed a different one? Sorry if I made that too hard.
2.
You do not momentarily unlock the shoulder to get this position, you go directly to it instead of the shoulder trap position. Same transition time either way. If you can get to the shoulder trap, you can get to this. It’s way easier to control this though, because it has the same control as the shoulder trap but is reinforced by your arm.
3. It IS basically options from a non-hand on the mat muddy waters. And it’s worked for me repeatedly in SEVERAL different gyms for a long time.
4. I almost don’t know how to respond “Also implying that someone could just shrug out of a sinched dead orchard is laughable.” I’ve been doing “dead orchard” type moves for over 3 years before it was called that. Including double digit #’s in competition. Check the thread where the “Dead Orchard” got its name. You can also find people shrugging out of the “dead orchard” in some of my competition videos. And on TONS of the videos that were posted after the move became popular. It’s happening all the time.