Great, well written read. I would have to say though, that we all got to win (which you more than alluded to when you stated both sides could claim victory).
I don't think both sides can claim victory, but certainly neither must admit a humiliating defeat. While we all look up to Eddie, it would be hard not to empathize with Royler, and even more so, Royler's students, and feel a little worried that he would be humiliated...again. We all wanted Eddie to win, and on so many levels, he did. I feel that for Royler's students, they can walk away and at least not feel totally embarrassed, while Eddie's students can claim many victories in seeing the moves and transitions we know so well displayed so effectively.
I am having a hard time articulating my thoughts here, but in short, although I was absolutely electric with anxiety watching the match, ecstatic for the good showing by Bravo, I couldn't help but feel bad for Royler's followers during the match...seeing their guy get worked like that. In a way I was happy the match ended in a "technical" draw, because I think if Eddie subbed Royler again (only by the grace of sheer adrenaline did the sub not come to pass in my opinion), the feud would have only gotten worse. With the current situation, no one can really argue the effectiveness of the 10P system (or Roylers ability to tolerate pain), but no one had to get 100% butt-hurt because their guy got subbed. In the grand scheme, I think it was better for JJ (IMHO).