
Originally Posted by
Craig Murray
I think that's the root of the "gi makes your nogi better"... if you spend 15 years learning how to "fight another guy for the covers", the idea that it's kind of silly and pointless, and slowly being phased out of top-level competition, must be terrifying.
Fight another guy for the covers? Could you explain that? I've actually never heard that expression before. edit: I get it. Pajamas. Covers. Nice.
By the way, I hope I don't catch heat for this but I really think that these days people take the "gi makes your nogi better" and "nogi makes your gi better" comments out of context.
I don't know if you were saying this or not but in general, I don't think anyone is suggesting anymore than training gi in preparation for a nogi tournament makes you do better at that tournament, or that training nogi for a gi tournament will help you at the tournament itself.
I think when people say it, what they mean is that certain aspects of each can help someone become a better overall grappler. For example, finishing submissions in nogi usually requires some sharper technique than in the gi. On the other hand, defending submissions is generally more difficult in the gi, because in nogi you can slip out of things a bit easier. This is one example of how doing both can be beneficial.
That said, people should do what they enjoy, and what they like. I will say that there are no top level teams that encourage gi training before nogi competitions. During nogi season, all the top teams are having their competitors train without the gi for ADCC, Nogi worlds, Nogi pans, you name it.
I also love that Eddie lets people teach things that he hasn't mastered. Eddie is a true student of the game, and if there's something with value, no matter who it is, he's always going to want to learn it. it's definitely refreshing and very cool. Not everyobdy is like that.