DUDE, order yourself a case of depends(they come in a very discreet unlabeled brown box), stash em next to the condoms in the night stand and CALL HER OVER! Soon as you pull out and take off YOUR condom you put on HER diaper, like a little swap. Failsauce for her trying to front like the overpowering stench of urine was actually her cumming. If you gotta piss everytime you cum honey I guess you just ain't orgasming around me. And yes, be glad it wasn't #2, but on the bright side you'd have hard evidence that you literally, "fucked the shit out of her"