Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 19 of 19
  1. #11
    Quote Originally Posted by Eddie Bravo View Post
    Roger Gracie said 80% of traditional gi jiu jitsu does not work in Mma. So for sure traditional gi jiu jitsu isn't the best form of grappling for Mma if what Roger said is true. That leaves judo, Sambo, catch wrestling, Japanese jiu jitsu, TPJJ, Greco roman and free style wrestling.
    I think Roger meant it as 80% of what Roger knows, doesn't work in MMA. This can be misleading because Roger must have a wealth of knowledge and 20% of his knowledge, is a ton. So the 20% that does work, is IMO more effective than whatever percentage of Judo, Sambo, Catch Wrestling etc... (excluding TPJJ because I see it as a flavor of BJJ) that works in MMA. When martial artists only trained one style back in the early ufc days, it was GJJ on top and not any sambo, judo, or catch wrestling guys. So that alone should be proof of BJJ's dominance as the superior grappling style. Even in No-Gi grappling, BJJ guys rule the world championships year after year. Of course you always have your exceptions though.

  2. #12

    Array

    School
    None
    Location
    California
    Posts
    244
    Quote Originally Posted by JusLove View Post
    I think Roger meant it as 80% of what Roger knows, doesn't work in MMA. This can be misleading because Roger must have a wealth of knowledge and 20% of his knowledge, is a ton. So the 20% that does work, is IMO more effective than whatever percentage of Judo, Sambo, Catch Wrestling etc... (excluding TPJJ because I see it as a flavor of BJJ) that works in MMA. When martial artists only trained one style back in the early ufc days, it was GJJ on top and not any sambo, judo, or catch wrestling guys. So that alone should be proof of BJJ's dominance as the superior grappling style. Even in No-Gi grappling, BJJ guys rule the world championships year after year. Of course you always have your exceptions though.
    You "think" that's what he meant, but that's clearly not what he said. But I do agree with your observation of BJJ though. Although it's all just jiu jitsu to me. Use what works and call it a day. More time spent talking about what's better is less time actually getting better, which is what it's all about.

  3. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by Frank R. View Post
    You "think" that's what he meant, but that's clearly not what he said. But I do agree with your observation of BJJ though. Although it's all just jiu jitsu to me. Use what works and call it a day. More time spent talking about what's better is less time actually getting better, which is what it's all about.
    I am well aware that I said "think". You can never be sure exactly what they mean when it's their second language. Regardless, 20% of all BJJ and 20% of what he knows, it's still a ton of technique that will overcome other grappling arts more often than not. I agree with you on not caring about discussing what's better, I was more annoyed with the OP blabbing out "TPJJ is the best JJ system" with no evidence to back up his claims. Had he written something out, good or bad I probably wouldn't have cared to reply lol

  4. #14

    Array

    School
    10th Planet Saint Paul
    Location
    Hastings, MN
    Posts
    66
    Freestyle wrestling is probably the most effective form of grappling in MMA right now, at least at the highest levels. At a lot of the local MN shows I've seen TONS of dudes getting subbed out by good JJ guys, but in the UFC the wrestlers are still winning at a very high rate. A lot of the wrestlers can easily shut down a good JJ guys game in the cage.

    It's hard to say whether or not 10PJJ is the best because there aren't a ton of dudes using it in the UFC (highest level). I know there are several, but the sample size isn't large enough. Most of the JJ guys aren't training 10PJJ. Is it more effective than traditional gi JJ? I would say that it almost certainly is. I don't think a lot of people would argue that but until someone starts finishing fights using the rubberguard, the truck, or some other unique 10PJJ setups it's going to be somewhat difficult to point to 10PJJ and say "It's the best grappling style in MMA."

  5. #15

    Array

    School
    10th Planet & Nova Uniao
    Location
    Kansas City
    Posts
    1,071
    Quote Originally Posted by Eddie Bravo View Post
    Roger Gracie said 80% of traditional gi jiu jitsu does not work in Mma. So for sure traditional gi jiu jitsu isn't the best form of grappling for Mma if what Roger said is true. That leaves judo, Sambo, catch wrestling, Japanese jiu jitsu, TPJJ, Greco roman and free style wrestling.
    TPJJ is the youngest of these arts, it's still in its infancy compared to the others age wise, therefore MMA fighters are less familiar with it and or have spent less time working the system into their game. Over time TPJJ will get even bigger and the guys training the system will get better and better at it. As this happens it will leave no doubt in anyones mind that 10th planet is the best. Get on board with the revolution now or get left behind people.

  6. #16
    Quote Originally Posted by Ryan Clinton View Post
    Freestyle wrestling is probably the most effective form of grappling in MMA right now, at least at the highest levels. At a lot of the local MN shows I've seen TONS of dudes getting subbed out by good JJ guys, but in the UFC the wrestlers are still winning at a very high rate. A lot of the wrestlers can easily shut down a good JJ guys game in the cage.

    It's hard to say whether or not 10PJJ is the best because there aren't a ton of dudes using it in the UFC (highest level). I know there are several, but the sample size isn't large enough. Most of the JJ guys aren't training 10PJJ. Is it more effective than traditional gi JJ? I would say that it almost certainly is. I don't think a lot of people would argue that but until someone starts finishing fights using the rubberguard, the truck, or some other unique 10PJJ setups it's going to be somewhat difficult to point to 10PJJ and say "It's the best grappling style in MMA."
    Well all those wrestlers train BJJ. I agree that Wrestling base + BJJ is better than BJJ base + wrestling because it's easier to learn BJJ defense than offense but a pure wrestler vs pure BJJ, the BJJ guy is going to win majority of the time.

  7. #17
    Brent Smith's Avatar
    Array

    School
    10th Planet Jiu Jitsu
    Location
    Medford, OR
    Posts
    5,810
    10th planet allows me to wear tights without looking like a fruitcake. That's the only reason I study it.
    #10thplanetFREAKS

  8. #18
    Chris Herzog's Avatar
    Array

    School
    10th Planet Rochester
    Location
    Rochester, Ny
    Posts
    7,339
    BTW Denny has 2 Worlds Championships under his belt. One as a Brown Belt at the No-Gi worlds. And the other at the FILA No-Gi Worlds.
    Check out my instructional website:www.zogipedia.com



    Head Coach 10th Planet Jiu Jitsu Rochester www.10thplanetjiujitsurochester.com

  9. #19
    Quote Originally Posted by Chris Herzog View Post
    BTW Denny has 2 Worlds Championships under his belt. One as a Brown Belt at the No-Gi worlds. And the other at the FILA No-Gi Worlds.
    I did not know that. Touche.

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •