i drill the sweep a bit as part of syllabus but when I'm actually rolling i never tend to use it - i focus mostly on using butterfly hooks for sweeping.
i think its because the scissors guard is more of an open guard that requires distance to set up, while my guard game probably focuses a bit too much on leaving minimum space to help transition into a tight rubber/butterfly guard
anyway, that's why i was wondering if you could transition into it from rubber guard, because if you just had new york you'd essentially already have a necktie, elbow control and broken posture right in front of you. the only obstacle is you'd have to make space to get that shin across their hip, and thats not easy while you have one of your legs hooking around their shoulders..
anyway you seem to be pretty well informed about this position.. iv still got a few things to sort out
- the shin that's going across their body, you have your foot hooking his hip; do you want your knee to be in anywhere in relation to your opponents body? or do you just make sure that its slightly above your foot?
- the arm that acts as a necktie (same side arm as shin across body), could you exchange it with other grips, like overhooks/underhooks etc?