Im not implying anything. Im saying your views on what is "your right to punish a kid" is completely retarded. I could understand if this girl had done something crazy and was a little hellian then sure beat her. I would be right there saying "she fuckin deserved it." But seriously this was a little over the top. Do you think this made her respect her parents any? What good do you think this does? I bet shes on the straight and narrow now huh?