Originally Posted by
Michael J Hewson
I don't agree with you Craig.
Yeah, well I was directly contradicting you so, that's kind of implied. No surprises there.
there are many many people who have studied this and like I said the majority have come to the conclusion that the number of jews that were killed is 6 million.
Ok name 5. Please cite me 5 peer reviewed scientific journal articles that break down how that 6 million number is derived. Obviously you dont just guess, so whoever came up with that based it on data. Find the article, find the data, and let's have a look.
You said "you cant bring 1 old document" but you brought so far, zero documents to the argument.
Again, you need to be bringing some good facts from reputable sources that back up your claims.
But he's not presenting these ideas for you to refute by quoting someone else. He's asking you to consider, with your own mind, what a human industrial crematorium looks like. How man sites were there, how many years, means how many bodies a day? How big were they? How long does it take to cremate one body? Now do the math.... you dont need other people's opinions to think about this subject.
My point was that you should think about things yourself, rather than rushing to what "many many" other people think.
You talk about facts. Here is one he gave that you keep ignoring. It's from the almanac, is that a bad source?
World Almanac, 1940, pg. 129: World Jewish Population -- 15,319,359
World Almanac USA, 1947, pg. 748: World Jewish Population -- 15,690,000
So, is that wrong? If so how? If not, then how do you explain the missing 6 million deaths? Maybe it IS wrong, but have you studied where that almanac gets it's figures from? How did they estimate?
Most of your argument boils down to "the majority of people agree with me". But what the majority believe has proven, over and over again, to be a bad way to tell true from false.
Bookmarks