
Originally Posted by
Kurzy
The Gi is like a cult in some cases.
I don’t want to take away from this awesome thread, but I really don’t understand this. This is a false dichotomy. There are gi vs. no-gi debates, but they exist entirely on the internet. No one training hard in jiu-jitsu in 2013 is having these discussions. They’re archaic and largely brought up by white belts or newer grapplers, and you’ll see people that have trained longer re-enter the debates with the same arguments and positions.
The majority of the modern grappling world does both and they don't have the time nor energy to debate which is better. Even the competitive season is arranged for the first half of the year to be gi season, and the 2nd half of the year is no-gi season. All of the top level gyms train both. I can think of a very very small number of athletes that only participate in gi or no-gi at purple, brown, and black. I’m not saying it’s wrong to do one or the other. I’m saying that there aren’t these gi gyms out there that rally against no-gi. I can’t think of any major team that doesn’t embrace intense no-gi training (Alliance, Atos, Gracie Barra, Checkmat, Nova Uniao, the list is endless).
No-gi is a major part of modern grappling, and I promise you that everyone serious about jiu-jitsu knows this.